
New Pass & City Island: A Sarasota Boater's Guide to Waterfront Dining, Fishing, Gulf Access, and Coastal Living
From burgers on the water to one of Sarasota's most important Gulf connections, discover why New Pass and City Island deserve a place on your boating itinerary.
New Pass & City Island: A Sarasota Boater's Guide to Waterfront Dining, Fishing, Gulf Access, and Coastal Living
From burgers on the water to one of Sarasota's most important Gulf connections, discover why New Pass and City Island deserve a place on your boating itinerary.
There are certain places in Sarasota that capture the feeling of Old Florida, even as the city around them continues to change.
For me, the New Pass and City Island area is one of those places.
Here, you can grab breakfast at a waterfront grill, pick up bait for a morning of fishing, watch boats travel through the pass, or simply enjoy the beautiful waters surrounding Lido Key and Longboat Key.
It's an area where recreational boating, marine science, fishing traditions, and Sarasota history all come together.
And if you're considering buying a waterfront home, New Pass is more than a destination. It's also an important part of understanding how boaters access the Gulf of Mexico from Sarasota Bay.
Let's explore what makes this area special, where to eat, what to know before navigating the pass, and why location matters when choosing a waterfront property.
Where Is New Pass in Sarasota?
New Pass is located between the southern end of Longboat Key and the northern end of Lido Key.
It connects Sarasota Bay with the Gulf of Mexico and is crossed by the New Pass Bridge along Gulf of Mexico Drive, also known as State Road 789.
Just east of the pass is City Island, accessible by Ken Thompson Parkway from Lido Key.
City Island is home to several Sarasota landmarks, including New Pass Grill & Bait Shop, The Old Salty Dog, and Mote Marine Laboratory's longtime research campus.
What makes this area particularly appealing is the combination of protected bay waters and access toward the Gulf.
You can enjoy waterfront dining, explore nearby islands, and observe boats making their way between Sarasota Bay and open water.
However, New Pass has an important reputation among experienced boaters: its navigation conditions require careful attention.
We'll get into that shortly.
A Little Sarasota History: How New Pass Got Its Name
New Pass has a fascinating history.
According to the history published by New Pass Grill & Bait Shop, the waterway was created by a hurricane in 1848.
The opening between the barrier islands became known as New Pass.
Over time, it developed into an important part of Sarasota's boating and fishing community.
The New Pass Bridge opened in 1929, the same year the original New Pass bait shop was established.
Think about that for a moment.
For nearly a century, people have been coming to this area to fish, buy bait, enjoy the water, and spend time along Sarasota Bay.
The surroundings have changed considerably, but the boating and fishing culture remains an important part of the area's identity.
New Pass Grill & Bait Shop: A Sarasota Tradition Since 1929
Address: 1505 Ken Thompson Parkway, Sarasota, FL 34236
Grill: 941-388-3050
Bait shop: 941-388-1618
Website: https://newpassgrill.com/
If you're looking for a waterfront destination that feels like a piece of Sarasota history, New Pass Grill & Bait Shop belongs on your list.
This isn't a formal dining experience with elaborate décor or an upscale dress code.
It's a relaxed waterfront grill with outdoor seating, beautiful views, and a long connection to Sarasota's fishing community.
And that's exactly what makes it appealing.
What Should You Order?
New Pass Grill is especially known for its burgers.
Its published menu highlights the New Pass Famous Angus Burger, along with seafood baskets, grouper, sandwiches, and breakfast selections.
It's the kind of place where you can enjoy a casual meal while watching the boats and taking in the scenery.
The grill currently advertises daily hours of 7 a.m. to 6 p.m., with breakfast served in the morning.
I always recommend confirming hours and menus before visiting.
The Bait Shop Is Part of the Experience
What makes this destination especially interesting is that the bait and tackle shop remains an important part of the business.
The shop advertises:
- Live and frozen bait
- Fishing tackle and terminal gear
- Fishing line, hooks, and rigs
- Ice and cold drinks
- Fishing pole rentals
- Information about local fishing conditions
The bait shop currently advertises a 6 a.m. opening, making it convenient for anglers planning an early departure.
For someone exploring Sarasota's boating culture, this is a great example of how fishing traditions and waterfront dining overlap.
Can You Arrive by Boat?
New Pass Grill & Bait Shop is located directly on the waterfront and has a dock associated with its bait shop and charter operations.
However, boaters should contact the business to confirm whether temporary docking is available for restaurant guests, as well as any vessel restrictions.
Never assume a dock is available simply because it's visible from the water.
The Old Salty Dog: A Classic City Island Waterfront Restaurant
Address: 1601 B Ken Thompson Parkway, Sarasota, FL 34236
Phone: 941-388-4311
Website: https://theoldsaltydog.com/
Another well-known City Island destination is The Old Salty Dog.
If you've spent much time around Sarasota, you've probably heard of it.
The City Island location offers a casual waterfront atmosphere that fits perfectly with a day spent exploring the bay.
It's known for its relaxed dining experience, seafood, sandwiches, and its signature hot dog.
What Makes The Old Salty Dog Popular?
Part of the appeal is its setting.
It's the kind of place where you can arrive dressed casually, enjoy the coastal atmosphere, and watch activity on the surrounding waterways.
For visitors, it offers a taste of Sarasota's laid-back boating culture.
For residents, it's one of those familiar places that can become part of a weekend routine.
Is The Old Salty Dog Accessible by Boat?
The City Island restaurant is located along the waterfront, and boaters have historically included it among Sarasota's dock-and-dine destinations.
However, docking policies and availability should always be confirmed directly with the restaurant before departure.
The restaurant currently advertises daily hours of 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.
Mote Marine Laboratory: An Important Change on City Island
If you've visited Sarasota for years, you may remember bringing family or friends to Mote Marine Laboratory & Aquarium on City Island.
For decades, Mote's public aquarium was one of the area's most recognizable attractions.
But there's an important update visitors should know.
The public aquarium on City Island closed in July 2025.
Mote opened its new Mote Science Education Aquarium, known as Mote SEA, near Nathan Benderson Park.
That means visitors should no longer travel to City Island expecting to tour the former public aquarium.
However, Mote's marine research operations remain on City Island.
The organization has announced plans to transform the original aquarium footprint into additional research and marine science facilities.
I think this is an interesting part of Sarasota's evolving identity.
City Island continues to connect our community with marine research and conservation, even as Mote's public aquarium experience has moved inland.
For current information, visit https://mote.org/.
Can You Reach the Gulf of Mexico Through New Pass?
Yes. New Pass connects Sarasota Bay to the Gulf of Mexico.
However, this is one of the most important parts of the guide.
New Pass should never be treated as a guaranteed navigable route simply because it appears on a map.
The inlet is known for shifting sand, shoaling, and challenging navigation conditions.
What Is Shoaling?
Shoaling occurs when sand accumulates in a waterway, reducing its navigable depth.
In a coastal pass, tides, currents, storms, and waves can continually reshape the bottom.
That means the location of deeper water may change.
A channel that was usable previously may become difficult or unsafe for a particular vessel.
New Pass Dredging and Navigation Conditions
New Pass is a federally authorized navigation project.
Dredging work in early 2026 was intended to improve navigability, but dredging does not eliminate the possibility of future shoaling.
A planned dredged depth should never be confused with a verified, current controlling depth.
Before attempting to navigate the pass, boaters should review the latest U.S. Coast Guard Local Notices to Mariners, available surveys, navigation aids, tides, and marine forecasts.
The West Coast Inland Navigation District specifically warns that inlet channels can change significantly after storms.
For unfamiliar boaters, obtaining current local knowledge from a qualified captain is particularly important.
What About New Pass Bridge?
The New Pass Bridge is a movable bascule bridge.
Boaters operating vessels that require an opening should check the current bridge operating regulations and contact procedures before departure.
Vessel height, tidal water level, and the bridge's published clearance all matter.
Do not rely on an old clearance figure or assume that a bridge will open immediately upon arrival.
How to Plan Your Route to New Pass and City Island
Whether you're heading to a restaurant, visiting the bait shop, or evaluating a possible Gulf-access route, marine navigation tools can help you begin planning.
Garmin Navionics Boating
Useful for reviewing nautical charts, navigation markers, and water-depth information.
Savvy Navvy
Can help you explore potential routes, distances, and estimated travel times based on vessel characteristics.
Argo Navigation
Offers marine route planning and community information about boating destinations.
Destinations to Search
Try entering these locations into your preferred boating app:
New Pass Bridge, Sarasota
New Pass Grill & Bait Shop
The Old Salty Dog, City Island
City Island, Sarasota
Longboat Key, southern end
Remember, a marine navigation app is a planning tool. It does not replace current official charts, navigation notices, or the judgment of a qualified captain.
Fishing Around New Pass
Fishing is an important part of New Pass's history and remains one of the reasons people visit the area.
The surrounding waters include tidal currents, channel edges, nearby grass flats, and other habitats that can attract different species of fish.
Depending on the season and conditions, anglers may target species such as:
Snook: Often associated with passes, current, structure, and moving baitfish.
Redfish: Commonly targeted around nearby shallow-water habitats, grass flats, and mangrove edges.
Spotted seatrout: Frequently associated with seagrass habitats throughout Sarasota Bay.
Sheepshead: Often found around pilings and other hard structures.
Spanish mackerel: May be encountered in coastal waters when baitfish are present.
Tarpon: Seasonal movements bring tarpon into Sarasota's coastal waters, particularly during warmer months.
The presence of these species varies with season, water temperature, tides, and other conditions.
And before keeping any fish, always verify current Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission regulations.
Species-specific seasons, size limits, bag limits, and special management areas can change.
For official regulations, visit:
https://myfwc.com/fishing/saltwater/recreational/
I'll be covering Sarasota's popular fishing destinations in a separate series, including what you're likely to catch, seasonal considerations, and the regulations anglers need to understand.
Other Places to Explore Near New Pass
South Lido Key
The southern end of Lido Key offers beaches, coastal scenery, and access to Sarasota Bay.
The Ted Sperling Park area is particularly known for paddling and mangrove environments.
Northern Lido Key
The northern end of Lido Key is adjacent to New Pass and offers views of the surrounding coastal waters.
Boaters should be cautious around the inlet and avoid assuming shallow shoreline areas are safe for landing.
Southern Longboat Key
Across New Pass, southern Longboat Key features waterfront neighborhoods, resorts, and scenic shoreline areas.
This part of the island is especially interesting to buyers who want to compare boating access toward New Pass with other Gulf connections.
Sarasota Bay
The protected waters of Sarasota Bay offer opportunities for scenic cruising, fishing, and exploring waterfront destinations.
Even within the bay, boaters must pay attention to marked channels, seagrass, shallow water, and speed restrictions.
What New Pass Can Teach You About Buying Waterfront Real Estate
As a Sarasota Realtor, one of the things I want waterfront buyers to understand is that not all Gulf access is created equal.
A listing might advertise direct water access or no fixed bridges.
But that doesn't necessarily mean the route is suitable for every boat or every boating activity.
New Pass is a perfect example of why understanding the waterway matters.
The Dock Is Only the Beginning
Before purchasing a waterfront home, I encourage buyers to investigate:
- The depth of the water at the dock
- Canal and channel depths along the route
- The boat's draft and overall height
- Fixed and movable bridges
- Tidal limitations
- Speed and wake restrictions
- Distance to preferred destinations
- Dock and lift permits
- Seawall condition
- Available alternative routes to the Gulf
A home can have a beautiful dock but still present boating limitations that affect how you use the property.
Waterfront Neighborhoods Worth Comparing
Bird Key
Located between downtown Sarasota and St. Armands Circle, Bird Key is an established luxury waterfront neighborhood.
Depending on the property and vessel, boaters can investigate routes toward New Pass and other Sarasota Bay destinations.
Country Club Shores
Located on southern Longboat Key, Country Club Shores offers canal-front homes and proximity to the New Pass area.
Individual canal depths, docks, and boating routes vary.
Lido Shores
This exclusive neighborhood on northern Lido Key includes waterfront properties in a setting close to New Pass.
It's particularly interesting for buyers who appreciate distinctive architecture and proximity to the coast.
Bay Isles and Southern Longboat Key
Waterfront properties in this broader area may appeal to buyers seeking access to Sarasota Bay, although navigability depends on the specific property and route.
Harbor Acres
Near downtown Sarasota, Harbor Acres offers another location to compare for boaters interested in waterfront living and access to Sarasota Bay.
Why I Encourage Buyers to Research More Than One Gulf Route
Suppose you're considering two waterfront properties.
Both have docks.
Both offer beautiful views.
Both are advertised as having Gulf access.
But one property's most convenient route may be through New Pass, while another offers a more practical route toward Longboat Pass or a different inlet.
Those differences can influence your boating experience.
For someone who enjoys leisurely bay cruises, they may be less important.
For someone planning frequent offshore fishing trips, they could be a major consideration.
That's why I recommend evaluating a waterfront property around the boat you own and the destinations you actually plan to visit.
Frequently Asked Questions About New Pass and City Island
Where is New Pass located?
New Pass is between southern Longboat Key and northern Lido Key in Sarasota, Florida. It connects Sarasota Bay with the Gulf of Mexico.
Can you reach the Gulf through New Pass?
New Pass is a Gulf connection, but navigability depends on current channel conditions, vessel characteristics, tides, and weather. Obtain current navigation information before attempting passage.
Is New Pass Grill & Bait Shop still open?
Yes. The business currently advertises daily grill and bait shop operations at 1505 Ken Thompson Parkway. Confirm hours before visiting.
What is New Pass Grill known for?
It's known for its longstanding bait shop, casual waterfront dining, burgers, seafood, and connection to Sarasota's fishing community.
Where is The Old Salty Dog on City Island?
The restaurant is located at 1601 B Ken Thompson Parkway, Sarasota.
Can you visit Mote Aquarium on City Island?
No. The public aquarium closed at its City Island location in July 2025. The new Mote Science Education Aquarium is near Nathan Benderson Park, while Mote's research operations remain on City Island.
Is New Pass good for fishing?
The pass and surrounding Sarasota Bay waters provide habitat for several popular saltwater species. Fishing success depends on season, tides, conditions, and regulations.
Does New Pass have a drawbridge?
Yes. New Pass Bridge is a movable bascule bridge. Check current opening regulations before your trip.
Can you dock at the restaurants on City Island?
Waterfront docking opportunities and policies vary by business. Contact each restaurant directly to confirm whether guest docking is currently available.
Is New Pass a good location for waterfront homeowners?
Its proximity to Sarasota Bay, Gulf access, restaurants, and boating destinations can be attractive. However, buyers should evaluate the specific property's navigation route, water depth, bridge considerations, and current inlet conditions.
Discover the Sarasota Lifestyle Beyond Your Dock
One of the reasons I love featuring Sarasota's boating destinations is that each one tells a different story.
Jewfish Key is known for its sandbar atmosphere.
Beer Can Island offers beautiful natural scenery.
Mar Vista and Shore showcase two very different waterfront dining experiences.
And New Pass brings together the history of Sarasota's fishing community, waterfront restaurants, marine science, and the practical realities of navigating between the bay and the Gulf.
If you're considering buying a waterfront home, these are the experiences worth thinking about.
Not simply whether a property has water behind it, but where that water can take you.
I'm Kelly Fullick, a Sarasota native and Realtor serving Sarasota and Manatee counties.
If you're exploring Sarasota waterfront real estate, I'd love to help you compare neighborhoods, boating routes, and the details that matter for your lifestyle.
Because the right waterfront home should offer more than a beautiful view. It should connect you with the Sarasota lifestyle you want to enjoy.
Kelly Fullick | Sarasota Real Estate
941.260.7770
Kelly@KellyFullick.com
www.KellyFullick.com
Boating conditions, restaurant hours, docking policies, marine navigation aids, and fishing regulations can change. Always consult current official sources and qualified marine professionals before making navigation decisions.
About Kelly Fullick
Kelly Fullick is a Sarasota-native Realtor with Coldwell Banker Realty. She specializes in helping out-of-state relocation buyers and Sarasota-area sellers with candid, education-first guidance. Kelly has closed 36+ transactions totaling over $18.6M across Sarasota and Manatee County since 2022, and holds a perfect 5.0-star rating on 25 Google reviews.

Ready to take the next step?
Let's Talk About Your Goals
Every situation is different. Schedule a no-pressure conversation with Kelly to get clear on your options.
941.260.7770
kelly@kellyfullick.com
Schedule a Consultation

