Waterfront patio at Shore Longboat Key overlooking Sarasota Bay at dusk
Local Life· 11 min read

Shore Longboat Key: Waterfront Dining, Boating Adventures, and the Restaurant's Return to St. Armands Circle

Shore Longboat Key brings contemporary coastal dining to Sarasota Bay with boat access and bay views. Here's what to know, plus what happened on St. Armands Circle and when Shore plans to return.

By Kelly Fullick · October 31, 2026
Local Life

Shore Longboat Key: Waterfront Dining, Boating Adventures, and the Restaurant's Return to St. Armands Circle

Discover one of Sarasota Bay's most stylish waterfront restaurants, its connection to St. Armands Circle, and why it's a destination worth exploring by boat.

One of the things I love about living in Sarasota is that going out to lunch or dinner can be an adventure in itself.

Instead of driving across town, imagine leaving your dock, cruising through Sarasota Bay, enjoying the coastal scenery, and arriving at a beautiful waterfront restaurant.

That's the lifestyle Shore Longboat Key represents.

Located along the bayside of northern Longboat Key, Shore combines contemporary coastal architecture, beautiful water views, and an elevated yet relaxed dining experience.

But there's more to Shore's story than its Longboat Key location.

Many Sarasota residents remember Shore's former restaurant on St. Armands Circle, which closed following the devastating hurricanes of 2024. That space is now occupied by Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar, but Shore has announced plans to return to the Circle at a new location.

So whether you're looking for your next boating destination, wondering what happened to Shore on St. Armands, or exploring the Sarasota waterfront lifestyle, here's what you should know.

Where Is Shore Longboat Key?

Address: 800 Broadway Street, Longboat Key, FL 34228

Phone: 941-259-4600

Location: Northern Longboat Key, overlooking Sarasota Bay

Nearby waterway: Longboat Pass

Website: https://www.dineshore.com/

Shore is located in the historic Longbeach Village area near the northern tip of Longboat Key.

It's just south of Longboat Pass, west of Jewfish Key, and near another popular waterfront restaurant, Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant.

This area is especially appealing to boaters because it offers access to several destinations within northern Sarasota Bay.

You can explore nearby islands, enjoy beautiful coastal scenery, and stop for waterfront dining without leaving the boating lifestyle behind.

What Makes Shore Longboat Key Special?

Contemporary Coastal Architecture

Shore isn't your typical rustic Florida seafood restaurant.

The Longboat Key location features clean architectural lines, a modern coastal aesthetic, and an open-air atmosphere designed to showcase Sarasota Bay.

When the restaurant opened in 2019, it brought a contemporary dining experience to a waterfront property with a long history.

The design includes expansive windows, outdoor seating, and architectural features intended to connect the restaurant with its waterfront surroundings.

It's a beautiful contrast to the historic Old Florida character found elsewhere on Longboat Key.

Beautiful Views of Sarasota Bay

The waterfront setting is one of Shore's biggest attractions.

Depending on where you're seated, you can enjoy views across the bay, passing boats, and the surrounding coastline.

There's something particularly enjoyable about dining near the water when you're not in a hurry.

Whether you're meeting friends for lunch or planning an evening out, the setting encourages you to slow down and enjoy where you live.

A Different Atmosphere From Mar Vista

Shore and Mar Vista are located near each other along Broadway Street, but they offer very different experiences.

Shore emphasizes contemporary design and modern coastal dining.

Mar Vista offers historic charm, mature trees, and a more traditional Old Florida atmosphere.

I've personally visited Mar Vista by boat with friends from church after departing from The Landings boat launch. We had a wonderful meal, and I was especially impressed by their Brussels sprouts!

Shore is another restaurant worth adding to your waterfront dining list, especially if you appreciate contemporary architecture and beautiful bay views.

A Little History: From Moore's Stone Crab to Shore

Before Shore opened on Longboat Key, the waterfront property was home to Moore's Stone Crab Restaurant.

Moore's opened in 1967 and became a familiar destination for generations of residents and visitors.

The restaurant was part of the island's dining history for decades.

Following the closure of Moore's, the property was redeveloped into the Shore Longboat Key location, which opened in 2019.

The transformation reflected a broader evolution occurring throughout Longboat Key.

While the island continues to preserve elements of its historic coastal character, it has also attracted modern architecture, luxury residential development, and contemporary dining concepts.

Shore is a particularly visible example of that combination.

What's on the Menu at Shore Longboat Key?

Shore focuses on contemporary American coastal cuisine, with seafood, fresh ingredients, and creative preparations.

Its published menus have featured a variety of dishes, including:

  • Pan-roasted grouper
  • Shrimp and scallops
  • Local snapper
  • Jumbo lump crab cakes
  • Calamari
  • Seafood salads
  • Burgers
  • Specialty appetizers and desserts

The restaurant also offers cocktails, wine, and other beverages.

If you're visiting for the first time, I recommend reviewing the current menu before arriving.

Menus, seasonal ingredients, prices, and daily specials can change.

Can You Arrive at Shore Longboat Key by Boat?

Shore's waterfront property includes docking facilities, making it a restaurant boaters can consider when planning an outing around northern Sarasota Bay.

However, I always recommend confirming current guest docking availability before departing.

Docking arrangements, vessel size limitations, and operating procedures may change.

Restaurant phone: 941-259-4600

What to Enter Into Your Marine Navigation App

Destination: Shore Longboat Key

Address: 800 Broadway Street, Longboat Key, Florida

Published location coordinates: Approximately 27.43566° N, 82.685178° W

Nearby navigation reference: Intracoastal Waterway Marker 39

These details can help identify the restaurant's general location on a marine chart.

They should not be treated as a guaranteed safe approach route.

Three Boating Navigation Apps Worth Exploring

Garmin Navionics Boating

https://www.navionics.com/

Useful for reviewing nautical charts, channel markers, water depths, and possible routes.

Savvy Navvy

https://www.savvy-navvy.com/

Helpful for exploring estimated travel distances, routes, and boating times based on vessel characteristics.

Argo Navigation

https://argonav.io/

Offers marine mapping, route planning, and boating community features.

When planning a trip, always consider the vessel's draft, current tides, weather, speed restrictions, and the latest navigation information.

Nearby Boating Destinations to Explore

One of the things that makes Shore appealing is its proximity to several popular destinations.

Jewfish Key

Jewfish Key is a small private residential island east of Longboat Pass.

The surrounding shallow-water and sandbar areas are popular with recreational boaters.

It's a destination worth exploring for those who enjoy relaxing on the water and spending time with friends.

Remember that the island itself is private property.

Beer Can Island, Also Known as Greer Island

Located at the northern tip of Longboat Key, Beer Can Island is known for its natural shoreline, driftwood, and beautiful coastal scenery.

It's especially appealing to photographers and nature lovers.

Boaters should observe posted restrictions and exercise caution around the currents and changing water depths near Longboat Pass.

Longboat Pass

Longboat Pass connects northern Sarasota Bay with the Gulf of Mexico.

For boaters traveling offshore, it's an important access point.

The pass has a movable bridge, tidal currents, and changing navigation conditions that require careful planning.

Coquina Beach

Across Longboat Pass on the southern end of Anna Maria Island, Coquina Beach offers a beautiful Gulf shoreline.

It's a scenic destination to explore, although boaters should verify safe and permitted access rather than assume they can land directly on the beach.

Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant

760 Broadway Street, Longboat Key

Mar Vista is another excellent waterfront dining option near Shore.

It features historic Old Florida charm, a beautiful outdoor dining setting, and dedicated docking facilities.

If you're spending the day exploring northern Sarasota Bay, both restaurants are worth knowing about.

What Happened to Shore on St. Armands Circle?

If you've lived in Sarasota for a while, you probably remember Shore's popular location on St. Armands Circle.

The restaurant was known for its contemporary atmosphere, shopping-district location, and rooftop dining experience.

Unfortunately, the 2024 hurricane season significantly affected businesses throughout St. Armands Circle.

Hurricanes Helene and Milton brought devastating flooding and damage to the area.

Shore's St. Armands location ultimately closed in December 2024.

For longtime residents and visitors, the closure marked the loss of a familiar dining destination.

But that wasn't the end of Shore's story on St. Armands.

Tommy Bahama Now Occupies Shore's Former Location

In September 2025, Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar opened at 465 John Ringling Boulevard, the space previously occupied by Shore.

The move was part of the ongoing changes taking place on St. Armands Circle following the hurricanes.

For visitors who remember dining at Shore in that building, it's important to know that the location now operates as Tommy Bahama.

But Shore hasn't abandoned its plans for St. Armands.

In fact, the restaurant is working toward a return to the Circle.

Shore Is Planning a Return to St. Armands Circle

As of October 2026, Shore has announced plans to develop a new location at 24 and 28 North Boulevard of the Presidents, near Madison Drive on St. Armands Circle.

The proposed project is more ambitious than simply reopening the former restaurant.

Plans have included:

  • A café and retail concept on the ground floor
  • A full-service Shore restaurant on the second floor
  • Potential additional uses on an upper level
  • Building improvements designed to address current flood protection requirements

The redevelopment reflects a challenge facing many businesses in coastal Sarasota.

After the 2024 hurricanes, property owners and business operators have had to consider not only restoration costs, but also future storm resilience, elevation requirements, and floodproofing regulations.

When Will Shore Reopen on St. Armands?

The latest publicly reported target has been late 2027, although a firm opening date has not been confirmed.

Earlier plans suggested the café and retail component could open before the full-service restaurant.

However, an October 2026 update indicated that the project was still working through development and floodproofing requirements.

That means the timeline could change.

For now, the Longboat Key restaurant remains the Shore location to visit.

Why Shore's Return Matters to Sarasota

I think this story is about more than one restaurant.

St. Armands Circle is one of Sarasota's most recognizable destinations.

Its restaurants, shops, architecture, and walkable streets have long contributed to the area's identity.

The 2024 hurricanes created significant challenges for local businesses and property owners.

Some businesses reopened.

Others relocated.

And some are still working through plans to rebuild or return.

Shore's proposed new location is an example of how redevelopment can involve balancing a community's history with the realities of building in a coastal environment.

For residents, business owners, and real estate buyers, it's a reminder that Sarasota's waterfront lifestyle comes with both extraordinary opportunities and important responsibilities.

Understanding flood exposure, insurance, construction requirements, and long-term property maintenance is essential when considering coastal real estate.

What Shore Can Teach Us About Waterfront Real Estate

As a Sarasota Realtor, I often encourage buyers to think beyond the property itself.

A waterfront home can have a beautiful view, private dock, and impressive outdoor living area.

But how does the location support the lifestyle you want?

Would you enjoy taking friends to lunch by boat?

Do you want easy access to the Gulf for fishing?

Are you interested in exploring sandbars and natural islands?

Or do you prefer cruising through protected waters and visiting waterfront restaurants?

Your answers can influence which neighborhoods are the best fit.

Waterfront Neighborhoods Worth Exploring

Northern Longboat Key

Properties in this area may appeal to buyers who want to investigate boating routes toward Longboat Pass, Shore, Mar Vista, and northern Sarasota Bay.

Country Club Shores

Located on southern Longboat Key, Country Club Shores includes canal-front homes with access toward Sarasota Bay.

Bird Key

This established luxury waterfront community near downtown Sarasota offers opportunities to explore different boating destinations throughout the bay.

Harbor Acres

Located near downtown Sarasota, Harbor Acres includes waterfront homes that may appeal to buyers interested in boating and proximity to city amenities.

Anna Maria Island and Bradenton Beach

These coastal communities offer waterfront living near northern Sarasota Bay and Longboat Pass, although navigable access varies by property.

Don't Just Ask Whether a Home Has Gulf Access

One of the most important questions I encourage waterfront buyers to ask is:

How convenient is this home's boating route for the destinations I actually want to visit?

A listing may advertise Gulf access, but that doesn't tell you everything.

You also need to understand water depth, bridges, speed restrictions, dock conditions, and the route from the property to your favorite destinations.

Those details can make a significant difference in how much you enjoy owning a waterfront home.

Frequently Asked Questions About Shore Longboat Key

Where is Shore Longboat Key located?

Shore is located at 800 Broadway Street on northern Longboat Key, overlooking Sarasota Bay.

Can you arrive at Shore Longboat Key by boat?

The waterfront property has docking facilities. Contact the restaurant directly to confirm current guest docking arrangements and availability before visiting.

Is Shore Longboat Key still open?

Yes. Shore Longboat Key continues to operate at 800 Broadway Street.

What happened to Shore on St. Armands Circle?

Shore's former St. Armands location closed in December 2024 following damage from Hurricanes Helene and Milton.

What restaurant replaced Shore on St. Armands?

Tommy Bahama Restaurant & Bar opened at Shore's former address, 465 John Ringling Boulevard, in September 2025.

Is Shore returning to St. Armands Circle?

Yes. Shore has announced plans for a new development at 24 and 28 North Boulevard of the Presidents.

When will the new Shore on St. Armands open?

Late 2027 has been reported as a tentative target, but the project remains subject to development requirements and no firm reopening date has been confirmed as of October 2026.

Is Shore near Mar Vista?

Yes. Both restaurants are located along Broadway Street on northern Longboat Key.

Is Shore a good destination for a boating day trip?

Its location near Longboat Pass, Jewfish Key, and northern Sarasota Bay makes it a destination worth considering for a boating excursion. Confirm docking and navigation conditions before traveling.

Discover the Sarasota Waterfront Lifestyle

One of the things I love about Sarasota is that every stretch of waterfront has its own personality.

Some destinations celebrate historic Old Florida charm.

Others reflect modern coastal design.

And some, like Shore, tell a story about how Sarasota continues to evolve.

Whether you're enjoying lunch overlooking Sarasota Bay, exploring nearby boating destinations, or watching the next chapter unfold on St. Armands Circle, Shore is part of the area's waterfront dining story.

I'm Kelly Fullick, a Sarasota native and Realtor serving Sarasota and Manatee counties.

If you're considering buying a waterfront home, I'd love to help you explore the neighborhoods, waterways, boating routes, and coastal lifestyle opportunities that fit the way you want to live.

Because finding the right waterfront home isn't just about the view. It's about everything waiting beyond your dock.

Kelly Fullick | Sarasota Real Estate
941.260.7770
Kelly@KellyFullick.com
www.KellyFullick.com

Restaurant operations, docking availability, menus, development plans, and projected opening dates may change. Information about Shore's St. Armands redevelopment reflects publicly reported plans as of October 2026. Always verify current details directly with the businesses and appropriate authorities.

Shore Longboat KeyLongboat Key waterfront diningShore St. Armands Circle reopeningSarasota Bay boatingLongboat Key restaurants

Know someone moving to Florida? Share this post

Email Text

About Kelly Fullick

Kelly Fullick is a Sarasota-native Realtor with Coldwell Banker Realty. She specializes in helping out-of-state relocation buyers and Sarasota-area sellers with candid, education-first guidance. Kelly has closed 36+ transactions totaling over $18.6M across Sarasota and Manatee County since 2022, and holds a perfect 5.0-star rating on 25 Google reviews.

📞 941-260-7770·✉️ Kelly@kellyfullick.com·kellyfullick.com

Kelly Fullick

Ready to take the next step?

Let's Talk About Your Goals

Every situation is different. Schedule a no-pressure conversation with Kelly to get clear on your options.

941.260.7770

kelly@kellyfullick.com

Schedule a Consultation

Kelly Fullick

Sarasota REALTOR®
Curating Gulf Coast luxury living.

Connect

941-260-7770
kelly@kellyfullick.com
423 St. Armands Circle
Sarasota, FL 34236

© 2026 Kelly Fullick. All rights reserved.

Licensed REALTOR® — Coldwell Banker Realty, Sarasota, Florida