
The Forest at Hi Hat Ranch Sarasota: Luxury Estate Homes, Property Values & the Future of Hi Hat Ranch
Custom estates on three- to six-acre homesites behind a gate off Clark Road, plus what the 13,000-home Hi Hat Ranch expansion approved this October could mean for privacy, traffic, and property values.
The Forest at Hi Hat Ranch Sarasota: Luxury Estate Homes, Property Values & the Future of Hi Hat Ranch
2026 Sarasota Neighborhood & Development Guide | By Kelly Fullick, Sarasota Realtor
Imagine driving beneath a canopy of centuries-old oak trees, past sprawling estates surrounded by acres of natural Florida landscape, where privacy is measured in acres rather than feet between neighboring homes.
Welcome to The Forest at Hi Hat Ranch, one of Sarasota's distinctive luxury estate communities.
Located east of Interstate 75 off Clark Road in Sarasota's 34241 ZIP code, The Forest offers something increasingly difficult to find: custom-built luxury homes on three- to six-acre homesites, mature landscaping, gated access, and the freedom of a more private residential lifestyle.
But beyond the established neighborhood, a much larger story is unfolding.
Hi Hat Ranch is preparing for one of the most significant residential expansions in Sarasota County, with a long-range development plan allowing more than 13,000 homes across approximately 10,000 acres.
For buyers and homeowners, this raises important questions. How will the surrounding landscape change? What new roads, schools, and amenities are planned? Will the expansion affect home values? And what makes The Forest different from the thousands of new homes coming to eastern Sarasota?
Let's explore what makes this community special and what the future may hold.
What Makes The Forest at Hi Hat Ranch Different?
The Forest is a private, gated luxury estate community developed around approximately 54 homesites spread across roughly 270 acres.
Unlike many newer Sarasota subdivisions, where homes occupy quarter-acre lots or smaller, The Forest offers properties generally ranging from three to six acres.
That extra space creates opportunities for substantial landscaping, outdoor entertaining, detached structures where permitted, and a greater sense of separation between neighboring homes.
The community's natural surroundings are equally distinctive.
Towering live oaks, pine trees, palmettos, lakes, and preserved vegetation contribute to an Old Florida atmosphere.
Wildlife sightings may include deer, wild turkeys, hawks, and other native species.
Rather than building around a large resort-style amenity center, The Forest emphasizes privacy, architecture, and the surrounding land.
For buyers who want a custom estate without the density of a conventional master-planned neighborhood, this can be particularly appealing.
Who Built the Homes in The Forest?
The Forest features custom and semi-custom luxury residences rather than a collection of standardized production floor plans.
Builders associated with the community include:
- John Cannon Homes
- Arthur Rutenberg Homes
- Anchor Builders
- Neal Signature Homes
- Lee Wetherington Homes
Because homes were individually designed, architectural styles, construction materials, floor plans, and finishes vary considerably.
Common Features in Forest Estate Homes
Depending on the property, buyers may find:
- Expansive single-story or two-story floor plans.
- Three- to six-acre homesites.
- Four or more bedrooms.
- Dedicated home offices, libraries, and media rooms.
- Gourmet kitchens with custom cabinetry and premium appliances.
- High ceilings and large entertaining spaces.
- Multicar garages and additional storage.
- Private swimming pools, spas, and outdoor kitchens.
- Large covered lanais and screened outdoor living areas.
- Mature landscaping and natural privacy buffers.
- Detached guest accommodations or additional structures where permitted.
- Long private driveways and substantial setbacks.
These features are not universal, and proposed improvements should be reviewed against the property's deed restrictions and applicable permitting requirements.
One of the greatest advantages of custom construction is individuality.
Two homes with similar square footage may offer very different architectural details, construction quality, outdoor living spaces, and long-term maintenance requirements.
For that reason, evaluating real estate in The Forest requires more than comparing price per square foot.
The Forest at Hi Hat Ranch Real Estate Market: 2026
The Forest is a relatively small luxury neighborhood, which means individual transactions have a substantial influence on market statistics.
Several multimillion-dollar sales were reported during the first seven months of 2026.
Recent Home Sales in The Forest
| Property | Closed Price | Closing Date |
|---|---|---|
| 10808 Leafwing Drive | $2,600,000 | July 20, 2026 |
| 10790 Leafwing Drive | $2,750,000 | June 5, 2026 |
| 9489 Swaying Branch Road | $2,425,000 | April 30, 2026 |
| 9291 Swaying Branch Road | $2,040,000 | March 30, 2026 |
Based on these four identified transactions, the median closed price was approximately $2.51 million.
However, this should not be interpreted as the market value of every property in the neighborhood.
Homes vary in acreage, construction year, architectural design, renovations, and overall condition.
A recently constructed estate on three acres may compete very differently from an older residence on six acres.
How Long Does It Take to Sell a Home in The Forest?
A published MLS-derived neighborhood summary reported a three-year median marketing time of approximately 186 days.
The same summary indicated that closed properties sold for approximately 94% of their listed prices, although the precise listing-price measure should be verified against the underlying MLS records.
Luxury estate homes often require longer marketing periods because the buyer pool is smaller and the properties are less interchangeable.
A home with substantial acreage, specialty construction, or a highly customized floor plan may appeal to a specific group of purchasers.
For sellers, accurate pricing and professional marketing are essential.
For buyers, longer marketing periods may create opportunities to negotiate, particularly when a property has been listed above comparable market values.
Have Home Values Appreciated Over the Past Six Years?
The Forest has experienced multimillion-dollar transactions and continued demand for custom estate properties.
However, a reliable six-year appreciation rate requires an analysis of comparable properties or repeat sales from 2020 through 2026.
Because relatively few homes sell each year, comparing annual neighborhood median prices can be misleading.
The most meaningful equity analysis considers the property's original purchase price, construction quality, acreage, improvements, and current comparable closed sales.
A homeowner who purchased in 2020 and invested in significant renovations may have experienced a very different change in equity from someone who purchased during the 2022 market peak.
For buyers and sellers, understanding those differences is essential.
HOA Fees, CDD Fees, and Ownership Expenses
The Forest is governed by a homeowners association responsible for maintaining certain community features and enforcing deed restrictions.
Published builder information lists HOA fees at approximately $2,300 quarterly, equivalent to $9,200 annually.
Reported association responsibilities include the electronic entrance gate, entrance landscaping, and maintenance of common-area appearance.
Fees and services should be verified with the association before purchasing.
The community is also commonly advertised as having no CDD fee.
Additional Expenses to Consider
Acreage properties may have ownership expenses that differ from conventional suburban homes.
These can include landscaping and tree maintenance, private irrigation systems, well and septic servicing, pool maintenance, homeowners insurance, and specialty equipment.
Buyers should also investigate drainage conditions, flood zones, roof age, hurricane protection, and the maintenance responsibilities associated with detached structures.
A beautiful acreage property can offer exceptional privacy, but understanding its ongoing expenses is part of making an informed purchase.
Hi Hat Ranch Expansion: What Is Coming to Eastern Sarasota?
While The Forest is an established luxury neighborhood, the surrounding Hi Hat Ranch landscape is preparing for significant long-term development.
The Turner family has owned and operated the ranch since 1943.
The broader ranch encompasses approximately 10,000 acres, and its master development framework allows more than 13,000 homes across multiple future villages.
The project could reshape a substantial portion of eastern Sarasota over the next several decades.
For current homeowners and prospective buyers, understanding this development is especially important.
October 2026: Sarasota County Approves Hi Hat Village 1
On October 7, 2026, Sarasota County commissioners voted 3–1 to approve rezoning for the first major residential village within Hi Hat Ranch.
Known as Hi Hat Village 1, the project encompasses approximately 2,000 acres and allows up to 3,000 homes.
The approval is a significant milestone, but it does not mean all homes or infrastructure will be constructed immediately.
Additional engineering, subdivision plats, permitting, utilities, and construction approvals are required.
Who Will Build the New Homes?
Pulte Homes and Lennar have been identified as the primary homebuilders for Village 1.
Development plans discussed during the approval process included approximately:
- 1,400 homes associated with Pulte Homes.
- 1,600 homes associated with Lennar.
- Six planned residential neighborhoods.
- Approximately 450 homes within a proposed attainable-housing component.
Early proposals described potential home prices ranging from approximately $370,000 to $1 million.
These figures are preliminary planning estimates, not confirmed builder price lists.
Unlike The Forest's three- to six-acre custom estate homesites, the new villages are expected to include more conventional residential lot sizes and housing types.
This difference may help distinguish the two markets.
What Amenities Are Planned for Hi Hat Ranch?
The broader development framework includes residential neighborhoods, commercial areas, schools, recreation facilities, open space, and new infrastructure.
Plans contemplate:
- Village centers with shopping and services.
- Commercial and neighborhood retail space.
- Future school sites.
- A proposed high school.
- A proposed K–8 school.
- A regional sports complex.
- Parks and recreational facilities.
- Road extensions and improvements.
- Preserved wetlands and natural open spaces.
Village 1 has been described as retaining approximately 57% of its land as open space.
However, planned facilities should not be confused with completed amenities.
Individual projects will depend on future approvals, financing, construction schedules, and public agency decisions.
Why the Village Center Matters
During the October 2026 approval process, county staff raised concerns about the timing of commercial development.
Without neighborhood shopping and services available early in the development, residents could be required to drive outside the village for everyday needs.
Commissioners approved an amendment intended to accelerate the village center's development.
The actual opening date and commercial tenants have not been established.
Hi Hat Ranch Expansion Timeline: What Happens Next?
1943: The Turner Family's Ranching Legacy Begins
The Turner family establishes the long-standing agricultural ownership associated with Hi Hat Ranch.
2021: Master Development Framework Approved
Sarasota County approves the broader planning framework allowing more than 13,000 homes and associated infrastructure across the ranch.
2025: Development and Infrastructure Discussions Continue
Planning discussions address transportation, drainage, environmental preservation, public services, and the requirements for future residential villages.
October 7, 2026: Village 1 Rezoning Approved
County commissioners approve the first major village, allowing up to 3,000 homes on approximately 2,000 acres.
2027 and Beyond: Engineering and Initial Construction
Site development, roads, utilities, permits, and subdivision approvals must progress before substantial residential construction.
A confirmed first-home delivery date was not established in the publicly reviewed reporting.
2030s Through the 2050s: Potential Additional Villages
Future phases may be developed as market conditions, infrastructure, and additional approvals allow.
The full project has been discussed on a development horizon extending toward approximately 2056, but that should be considered a planning horizon rather than a guaranteed completion date.
How Will Roads and Traffic Change?
Transportation is one of the most important issues surrounding the Hi Hat Ranch expansion.
Thousands of additional homes will create new demand on existing roads, including Clark Road, Bee Ridge Road, Fruitville Road, and the eastern Sarasota transportation network.
Several improvements are planned or being evaluated.
Bee Ridge Road Improvements
Village 1 includes plans to extend Bee Ridge Road and improve portions of the existing corridor.
Public reporting described approximately $14 million in developer contributions toward widening, with a potential county contribution of a similar amount.
Additional roadway connections and a proposed roundabout are also part of the planning discussions.
These improvements are intended to support future development, but the final construction schedule remains subject to engineering and funding.
Lorraine Road Extension
Separate regional infrastructure projects include the planned Lorraine Road extension between Fruitville Road and Palmer Boulevard.
Additional improvements to Fruitville Road are also planned.
These projects could eventually improve north-south accessibility through eastern Sarasota.
However, improved road connections do not necessarily guarantee shorter travel times.
Future traffic volumes, construction activity, and the timing of surrounding development will influence how these roads function.
For homeowners in The Forest, monitoring these projects will be important as eastern Sarasota continues to grow.
Environmental Preservation, Wetlands, and Flooding Concerns
Hi Hat Ranch includes extensive natural landscapes, wetlands, and wildlife habitat.
The proposed development incorporates substantial open-space commitments, but environmental preservation remains an important topic.
Some residents and environmental advocates have expressed concerns about the effects of development on drainage systems, wildlife movement, and wetland connectivity.
These concerns received additional attention following severe flooding in parts of eastern Sarasota during 2024.
Developers have described plans incorporating stormwater infrastructure and protected open space.
However, buyers should understand that regional drainage and environmental conditions can change as development progresses.
For any property in The Forest, I recommend reviewing FEMA flood maps, elevation information, historical flooding disclosures, drainage characteristics, and available insurance information.
A property located outside a designated high-risk flood zone can still experience flooding during extreme rainfall.
What Could Hi Hat Ranch's Expansion Mean for Property Values in The Forest?
This is one of the most interesting questions for homeowners and buyers.
The Forest and the future Hi Hat villages are likely to serve different segments of the housing market.
The Forest offers large acreage, established landscaping, custom architecture, and substantial privacy.
The new villages are expected to provide a wider variety of homes, generally on smaller lots, with access to planned neighborhood amenities and commercial services.
These differences may help preserve The Forest's distinct market position.
Potential Benefits
As eastern Sarasota develops, additional shopping, dining, schools, recreational facilities, and transportation connections could improve everyday convenience.
The Forest may also gain visibility among buyers exploring luxury real estate in the surrounding region.
For some purchasers, an established estate community close to newer conveniences may be particularly appealing.
Potential Challenges
Large-scale construction can bring increased traffic, temporary road disruptions, changes to surrounding landscapes, and additional pressure on infrastructure.
Buyers attracted to The Forest because of its rural surroundings should consider how the surrounding region may evolve.
Will Home Values Increase?
No development project can guarantee future appreciation.
Property values depend on market conditions, buyer demand, comparable sales, property condition, and the characteristics of each home.
However, The Forest's limited inventory and substantial homesites provide a different ownership experience from conventional new construction.
That distinction is worth considering when evaluating long-term resale potential.
If you are comparing gated east-county alternatives, my guides to The Founders Club and The Concession explain how those golf communities differ in pricing, fees, and daily lifestyle.
What Schools Serve The Forest at Hi Hat Ranch?
Public school assignments commonly associated with The Forest include:
- Lakeview Elementary School
- Sarasota Middle School
- Riverview High School
School attendance boundaries can change, and buyers should verify assignments using the specific property address through Sarasota County Schools.
The broader Hi Hat Ranch development includes proposed future school sites, but their construction and opening schedules have not been finalized.
Families should not assume that proposed schools will be available by a particular date.
Is The Forest at Hi Hat Ranch a Good Place to Buy Luxury Real Estate?
For buyers seeking privacy, substantial acreage, and custom architecture, The Forest offers a compelling alternative to more densely developed Sarasota neighborhoods.
Its limited number of homesites, mature landscaping, and established estate properties make it distinctive within the local luxury market.
However, purchasing an acreage property requires careful evaluation.
Buyers should consider the condition of the residence, land elevation, drainage, insurance expenses, well and septic systems, HOA restrictions, and ongoing maintenance.
The surrounding Hi Hat Ranch expansion adds another important factor: understanding how future development may affect accessibility, privacy, and the neighborhood's character.
For sellers, the marketing strategy should communicate the property's unique characteristics rather than relying solely on square footage or neighborhood averages.
The right buyer is often looking for something that cannot easily be duplicated in a conventional subdivision.
Thinking About Buying or Selling in The Forest at Hi Hat Ranch?
Luxury real estate requires more than beautiful photography and an impressive listing description.
It requires understanding the land, the home, the surrounding community, and the market conditions influencing buyer decisions.
I'm Kelly Fullick, a Sarasota and Manatee County Realtor, helping buyers and sellers navigate distinctive properties, custom estates, and luxury neighborhoods throughout our region.
Whether you're exploring The Forest at Hi Hat Ranch, considering a move to eastern Sarasota, or evaluating the current market value of your property, I can help you understand the details that matter.
You can also browse Sarasota luxury homes currently on the market, or start with my Sarasota relocation guide if you are still planning the move.
Let's find the property that fits your lifestyle and makes sense in today's market.
Kelly Fullick
Sarasota & Manatee County Realtor
941.260.7770
Kelly@KellyFullick.com
www.KellyFullick.com
Market information and development details reflect publicly reported information available as of October 31, 2026. Future construction schedules, approved uses, HOA fees, school assignments, and market conditions are subject to change. Buyers should independently verify property-specific information before making purchase decisions.
About Kelly Fullick
Kelly Fullick is a Sarasota-native Realtor with Coldwell Banker Realty. She specializes in helping out-of-state relocation buyers and Sarasota-area sellers with candid, education-first guidance. Kelly has closed 36+ transactions totaling over $18.6M across Sarasota and Manatee County since 2022, and holds a perfect 5.0-star rating on 25 Google reviews.

Ready to take the next step?
Let's Talk About Your Goals
Every situation is different. Schedule a no-pressure conversation with Kelly to get clear on your options.
941.260.7770
kelly@kellyfullick.com
Schedule a ConsultationMore from the Journal

Neighborhood Guides
Longboat Key vs. Siesta Key vs. Casey Key: Which Sarasota Waterfront Lifestyle Fits You?

Neighborhood Guides
Country Club vs. Country Club East in Lakewood Ranch: Homes, Golf, Amenities & 2026 Market Guide

Neighborhood Guides