Client Stories

What Clients Say

"We can't say enough wonderful things about working with Kelly. From start to finish, she was incredibly helpful, knowledgeable, and genuinely caring. Unlike many realtors who are just focused on making a sale, she truly had our best interests at heart. She took the time to understand what we were looking for, and she went above and beyond to make sure we were informed and comfortable every step of the way. Her expertise and insight of Sarasota and the surrounding areas made a world of difference. Kelly was patient, attentive, and always had a positive attitude, even when challenges arose. If you're looking for a realtor who will treat you like family and work tirelessly to help you find the perfect home, we highly recommend Kelly Fullick. She's not just a realtor; she's a partner who genuinely cares about your happiness and well-being."

Tyler Koch

Buyer · Single Family · Google

"Kelly has exceeded my expectations during EVERY step during our selling of the home. I wouldn't ever have another realtor besides her should I need one in the future. Her knowledge and experience is second to none!!!!!!!"

B

Bradley Lemerise

Seller · Single Family · Google

Jul 2026

"Kelly was absolutely exempliary. Her excellence & her knowledge of real estate was beyond our expectations. Thank you Kelly for helping us purchase our new home with ease and to sell our old home."

s

sidney karr

Both · Single Family · Google

Jul 2026

"I can't speak highly enough of Kelly! She made an incredibly stressful home-buying situation as smooth as possible and handled a difficult seller with the utmost professionalism. And she's a wonderful human being to boot! I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home in and around Sarasota."

K

Kathy Bianchi

Buyer · Single Family · Google

Jul 2026

"Kelly was an exceptional agent to work with and I look forward to working with her again! We had various issues that were not easy but she never gave up! End result: happy buyers and sellers. Thank you, Kelly!"

T

Tracy Seider - The Seider Group

Both · Single Family · Google

Jul 2026

"Working with Kelly to sell our home was an amazing experience! She's not only super knowledgeable but also incredibly responsive—we always got answers fast, and she explained everything so clearly. No fluff, just straight-up helpful info and guidance. Anytime we had a question, she had the answer or immediately reached out to the right people. We felt totally confident throughout the whole process because we knew she had our back. Kelly made what could've been a stressful experience feel smooth and easy. We're so glad we had her on our side and highly recommend her to anyone looking to sell or buy!"

A

Andrea Kamay

Seller · Single Family · Google

Jul 2025

"Kelly was fantastic in assisting us in buying our first home in Florida. She is a wealth of information, quick to respond by email and text, eager and happy to show us a ton of houses to ensure we found just the right house for us. Stood beside us through every step of the home buying process, and made the entire experience fun and joyful. Highly recommend Kelly Fullick as a realtor. Thanks, Kelly!"

M

Mary West

Buyer · Single Family · Google

Mar 2024

"Kelly was an absolute pleasure to work with throughout the entirety of our purchasing process. After dealing with another agent's incompetence for 3 months, Kelly provided a breath of fresh air from day 1. Communication was flawless, all questions were answered, and I felt that she truly had our best interest in mind. If you're looking for an agent local to Sarasota, I suggest you look no further, Kelly is most definitely the best option out there."

M

Michael Radey

Buyer · Single Family · Google

Aug 2023

"Kelly is amazing! She helped us purchase an investment property recently and she made it an easy process as we currently live out of state. Kelly listens to what you are looking for in a home and what the dealbreakers are so she's not wasting your time. She is very knowledgeable and quick to respond to any questions. She followed the transaction all the way to closing so the property closed on time with no issues. I can't say enough great things about Kelly. Her professionalism and kindness sets her apart. We will definitely use her for future purchases."

T

Tara Hizon

Buyer · Investment · Google

May 2024

"Kelly and her buyers were a pleasure to work with for sellers I represented in Arlington Park. I was impressed with her ability to bring well qualified buyers to the table and close on time. Her communication throughout the transaction was excellent and we worked as a team to get to the finish line. I would certainly appreciate the opportunity to co-broke with Kelly again!"

A

Adam Rovithis

Buyer · Single Family · Google

Jan 2025

"Kelly Fullick is a true real estate professional in every aspect! She is a true pleasure to work with and you will not be disappointed in the job she does for you, either if hiring her as a Buyer Agent or as a Listing Agent. She truly values her clients and works with absolute diligence to create a positive outcome for them. Her understanding of the current real estate market in both Sarasota & Manatee Counties is unparalleled and she is a trusted source in the areas of negotiating for the best interest of her clients and their bottom line. I can personally attest to her professionalism and spirit of cooperation with other Realtors in the local real estate community. You cannot go wrong with hiring Kelly to represent you when either buying or selling a home!"

H

Heather Gehan

Both · Single Family · Google

Nov 2024

"Kelly was an absolute dream to work with. She was on top of EVERYTHING. She was my bank of knowledge, helped me navigate scenarios I didn't expect, was a liaison with everyone (including inspectors, contractors, you name it) and is frankly, a badass of a woman. She was my rock through communication, staging, scheduling, negotiating and being available for an ear when I needed to talk through any point of the selling process. I would 1000% recommended Kelly!! Thank you so much - you are THE BEST!"

J

Juliana Montane

Seller · Single Family · Google

Jun 2025

"Kelly is an exceptional realtor and an absolute pleasure to work with. She was highly professional, incredibly flexible with her schedule, and made the entire selling process smooth and stress-free. Thanks to her expertise and strategic approach, my home sold in just one day—even in a challenging market! The photos she arranged were stunning, and she handled every detail with efficiency and care. I couldn't have asked for a better experience."

N

Nicole

Seller · Single Family · Google

Jun 2025

"We can't say enough wonderful things about working with Kelly. From start to finish, she was incredibly helpful, knowledgeable, and genuinely caring. Unlike many realtors who are just focused on making a sale, she truly had our best interests at heart. She took the time to understand what we were looking for, and she went above and beyond to make sure we were informed and comfortable every step of the way. Her expertise and insight of Sarasota and the surrounding areas made a world of difference. Kelly was patient, attentive, and always had a positive attitude, even when challenges arose. If you're looking for a realtor who will treat you like family and work tirelessly to help you find the perfect home, we highly recommend Kelly Fullick. She's not just a realtor; she's a partner who genuinely cares about your happiness and well-being."

T

Tyler Koch

Buyer · Single Family · Google

Aug 2024

"Kelly is patient, proactive and knowledgeable. She was a critical part of our home search since we were out of area buyers. She was able to assess our preferences and was able to schedule showings that were spot on to our criteria. She offered a friendly reassuring voice of reason in a competitive real estate marketplace. Kelly's professionalism and energy made the whole home buying experience better than could be asked."

J

John Aikens

Buyer · Single Family · Google

May 2024

"Kelly is incredibly down to earth and helpful through the transaction process. She's a great and active communicator, which provides added reassurance. As a long time local, she is able to provide insight to the area that is incredibly helpful for those relocating. We felt very well represented!"

J

John

Buyer · Relocation · Google

Jul 2023

"I heard of Kelly through a coworker and I'm so glad we did! Her energy is great, her enthusiasm is contagious, and her genuine desire to help was just such a perfect match. As a first time home buyer, there is SO much to learn. And Kelly truly made us feel taken care of. She was very available and responsive while also letting us know reasons/times that she wasn't available. She was able to tactfully negotiate and we were all able to agree on a lower price that made everyone happy and today it is our home! She did the leg work and connected us with a plumber and an electrician who both had estimates for us within days. Should we find ourselves selling this home or buying a second, we'd absolutely call Kelly again. Thanks!!"

A

Amie Ouellette

Buyer · Single Family · Google

Jan 2025

"Working with Kelly was one of the smoothest processes I've ever undergone! As a first time home buyer, I wasn't sure what to expect— she made everything simple, efficient, and was prepared with specs on all of our house visits to answer any questions we could have had. Kelly was set on helping us not just close on a house, but find a home. 12/10 would recommend working with her!"

A

Anna Mccloskey

Buyer · Single Family · Google

Jul 2023

"Kelly was amazing. We were in a hurry to see the place and she came over immediately. Put an offer in same day and got us a no haggle acceptance instantly. Stayed on top of every aspect to close quickly. Then provided above expectations services after closing. Highly recommend her!"

T

Tim Self

Buyer · Single Family · Google

Aug 2024

"Two years ago we started looking into houses in the Sarasota area. When we found one online, we were very fortunate that Kelly became our agent. Words cannot express how Kelly was so responsive, thorough and such a pleasure to work with. She went up and beyond expectations. If and when another property comes into our interest, Kelly is our choice."

B

Bob Lammon

Buyer · Single Family · Google

May 2023

"She's amazing! When it was time to sell our beloved family home, I knew right away Kelly was the perfect fit. From our first consultation all the way through closing, her communication, knowledge and work ethic were all top notch. I highly recommend anyone looking to buy or sell to have Kelly represent you. She and her team all have your back and make a big life decision an easy and enjoyable process."

J

Jackson Haskins

Seller · Single Family · Google

Aug 2023

"Kelly first listened well to understand my needs and goals as I sold my condo and purchased a house. There was a lot happening… all at the same time in that scenario, but she stayed on top of the details and went above and beyond to help make sure the transactions went smoothly. She's an amazing realtor, but also a delightful, kind person who was a joy to work with."

K

Karen Slabach

Both · Condo · Google

May 2023

"Working with Kelly throughout our home buying process was an absolute pleasure. From day one, she was incredibly quick and responsive—no question went unanswered for long, and every step moved forward without delay. Her timeliness kept us on track and gave us peace of mind in what can be a stressful time. What truly set her apart, though, was her honesty. She offered transparent guidance and genuine insights at every turn, helping us make informed decisions without feeling pressured. It was clear she had our best interests at heart, and that trust meant everything. Thanks to her dedication, we felt confident and supported from offer to closing. I couldn't recommend her more highly for anyone looking for a reliable and honest realtor."

M

Melissa Raga

Buyer · Single Family · Google

Aug 2025

"Kelly represented a buyer in a transaction where I represented the seller. Her communication was prompt, professional and courteous. It was obvious she cared about her buyer interests. She was diligent in her assistance to handle the many bumps in the road that is a real estate transaction. I would be happy to work with her again."

B

Brian Shaefer

Buyer · Single Family · Google

Aug 2025

"Kelly is a standout and amazing realtor, we have had the pleasure of working with her during the buying and selling of many properties. We have observed that she is extremely diligent in regards to her clients needs and making sure that they get a great outcome whether it is buying or selling their home. In terms of working with her as a trades professional it's always a breeze — quick answers on emails, available on the phone, etc.!"

T

Trust Roofing

Both · Single Family · Google

Feb 2026

"We are delighted to recommend Kelly Fullick. She sold our home before it officially went on the market for full price and a short escrow! Naturally we were thrilled. Moreover, she was the consummate professional. She always took the higher ground, kept us informed of all details, big and small, and anticipated and conquered a few speed bumps. Her calm, pragmatic and positive attitude was only outmatched by her extensive knowledge and expertise. We would work with her again in a heartbeat."

J

June Battersby

Seller · Single Family · Google

Jan 2026

25 Five-Star Google Reviews

What Clients Are Saying

Bradley Lemerise

2026-07-21

Kelly has exceeded my expectations during EVERY step during our selling of the home. I wouldn't ever have another realtor besides her should I need one in the future. Her knowledge and experience is second to none!!!!!!!

sidney karr

2026-07-20

Kelly was absolutely exempliary. Her excellence & her knowledge of real estate was beyond our expectations. Thank you Kelly for helping us purchase our new home with ease and to sell our old home.

Kathy Bianchi

2026-07-10

I can't speak highly enough of Kelly! She made an incredibly stressful home-buying situation as smooth as possible and handled a difficult seller with the utmost professionalism. And she's a wonderful human being to boot! I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home in and around Sarasota.

Tracy Seider - The Seider Group

2026-07-02

Kelly was an exceptional agent to work with and I look forward to working with her again! We had various issues that were not easy but she never gave up! End result: happy buyers and sellers. Thank you, Kelly!

Trust Roofing

2026-02-17

Kelly is a standout and amazing realtor, we have had the pleasure of working with her during the buying and selling of many properties.. We have observed that she is extremely diligent in regards to her clients needs and making sure that they get a great outcome whether it is buying or selling their home. In terms of working with her as a trades professional it's always a breeze quick answers on emails available on the phone, etc. etc.!

June Battersby

2026-02-05

We are delighted to recommend, Kelly Fullick. She sold our home before it officially went on the market for full price and a short escrow! Naturally we were thrilled. Moreover, she was the consummate professional. She always took the higher ground, kept us informed of all details, big and small, and anticipated and conquered a few speed bumps. (There are always a few after all.) Her calm, pragmatic and positive attitude was only outmatched by her extensive knowledge and expertise. We would work with her again in a heartbeat.

Brian Shaefer

2025-07-16

Kelly represented a buyer in a transaction where I represented the seller. Her communication was prompt, professional and courteous. It was obvious she cared about her buyer interests. She was diligent in her assistance to handle the many bumps in the road that is a real estate transaction. I would be happy to work with her again.

Melissa Raga

2025-07-16

Working with Kelly throughout our home buying process was an absolute pleasure. From day one, she was incredibly quick and responsive—no question went unanswered for long, and every step moved forward without delay. Her timeliness kept us on track and gave us peace of mind in what can be a stressful time. What truly set her apart, though, was her honesty. She offered transparent guidance and genuine insights at every turn, helping us make informed decisions without feeling pressured. It was clear she had our best interests at heart, and that trust meant everything. Thanks to her dedication, we felt confident and supported from offer to closing. I couldn't recommend her more highly for anyone looking for a reliable and honest realtor.

Andrea Kamay

2025-06-09

Working with Kelly to sell our home was an amazing experience! She's not only super knowledgeable but also incredibly responsive—we always got answers fast, and she explained everything so clearly. No fluff, just straight-up helpful info and guidance. Anytime we had a question, she had the answer or immediately reached out to the right people. We felt totally confident throughout the whole process because we knew she had our back. Kelly made what could've been a stressful experience feel smooth and easy. We're so glad we had her on our side and highly recommend her to anyone looking to sell or buy!

Juliana Montane

2025-05-25

Kelly was an absolute dream to work with. She was on top of EVERYTHING. She was my bank of knowledge, helped me navigate scenarios I didn't expect, was a liaison with everyone (including inspectors, contractors, you name it) and is frankly, a badass of a woman. She was my rock through communication, staging, scheduling, negotiating and being available for an ear when I needed to talk through any point of the selling process. I would 1000% recommended Kelly!! Thank you so much - you are THE BEST!

Nicole

2025-05-25

Kelly is an exceptional realtor and an absolute pleasure to work with. She was highly professional, incredibly flexible with her schedule, and made the entire selling process smooth and stress-free. Thanks to her expertise and strategic approach, my home sold in just one day—even in a challenging market! The photos she arranged were stunning, and she handled every detail with efficiency and care. I couldn't have asked for a better experience.

Amie Ouellette

2025-01-30

I heard of Kelly through a coworker and I'm so glad we did! Her energy is great, her enthusiasm is contagious, and her genuine desire to help was just such a perfect match. Fast forward to today; our closing day! On our first home!! When we saw this home come up, it was a bit out of our budget but we wanted to see it because we were motivated to buy and knew that Kelly wouldn't pressure us anyways if it wasn't our home. Then we find out that the seller was also very motivated! She was able to tactfully negotiate and we were all able to agree on a lower price that made everyone happy and today it is our home! As a first time home buyer, there is SO much to learn. And Kelly truly made us feel taken care of. After learning of possible electrical or plumbing work, I asked her how I should find someone. She did the leg work and connected us with a plumber and an electrician who both had estimates for us within days. She was very available and responsive while also letting us know reasons/times that she wasn't available. But to be honest, I can't even recall an instance where she didn't make a showing work within our asking timeframe. Should we find ourselves selling this home or buying a second, we'd absolutely call Kelly again. Thanks!!

Adam Rovithis

2025-01-28

Kelly and her buyers were a pleasure to work with for sellers I represented in Arlington Park. I was impressed with her ability to bring well qualified buyers to the table and close on time. Her communication throughout the transaction was excellent and we worked as a team to get to the finish line. I would certainly appreciate the opportunity to co broke with Kelly again!

Heather Gehan

2024-11-21

Kelly Fullick is a true real estate professional in every aspect! She is a true pleasure to work with and you will not be disappointed in the job she does for you, either if hiring her as a Buyer Agent or as a Listing Agent. She truly values her clients and works with absolute diligence to create a positive outcome for them. Her understanding of the current real estate market in both Sarasota & Manatee Counties is unparalleled and she is a trusted source in the areas of negotiating for the best interest of her clients and their bottom line. I can personally attest to her professionalism and spirit of cooperation with other Realtors in the local real estate community. You cannot go wrong with hiring Kelly to represent you when either buying or selling a home!

Tyler Koch

2024-08-12

We can't say enough wonderful things about working with Kelly. From start to finish, she was incredibly helpful, knowledgeable, and genuinely caring. Unlike many realtors who are just focused on making a sale, she truly had our best interests at heart. Throughout the process, it was clear that Kelly wasn't just trying to sell us a house; she was dedicated to helping us find a home that would fit all of our needs and more. She took the time to understand what we were looking for, and she went above and beyond to make sure we were informed and comfortable every step of the way. Her expertise and insight of Sarasota and the surrounding areas made a world of difference, and we always felt like we were in good hands. Kelly was patient, attentive, and always had a positive attitude, even when challenges arose. Her commitment to her clients is truly exceptional, and we are so grateful for her guidance and support, even after we closed. If you're looking for a realtor who will treat you like family and work tirelessly to help you find the perfect home, we highly recommend Kelly Fullick. She's not just a realtor; she's a partner who genuinely cares about your happiness and well-being.

Tim Self

2024-08-02

Kelly was amazing. We were in a hurry to see the place and she came over immediately. Put an offer in same day and got us a no haggle acceptance instantly. Stayed on top of every aspect to close quickly. Then provide above expectations services after closing. Highly recommend her!

Tara Hizon

2024-05-21

Kelly is amazing! She helped us purchase an investment property recently and she made it an easy process as we currently live out of state. Kelly listens to what you are looking for in a home and what the dealbreakers are so she's not wasting your time. She is very knowledgeable and quick to respond to any questions. She followed the transaction all the way to closing so the property closed on time with no issues. I can't say enough great things about Kelly. Her professionalism and kindness sets her apart. We will definitely use her in for future purchases.

John Aikens

2024-05-08

Kelly is patient, proactive and knowledgeable. She was a critical part of our home search since we were out of area buyers. She was able to assess our preferences and was able to schedule showings that were spot on to our criteria. She offered a friendly reassuring voice of reason in a competitive real estate marketplace. Kelly's professionalism and energy made the whole home buying experience better than could be asked.

Mary West

2024-03-01

Kelly was fantastic in assisting us in buying our first home in Florida. She is a wealth of information, quick to respond by email and text, eager and happy to show us a ton of houses to ensure we found just the right house for us. Stood beside us through every step of the home buying process, and made the entire experience fun and joyful. Highly recommend Kelly Fullick as a realtor. Thanks, Kelly!

Jackson Haskins

2023-08-18

She's amazing! When it was time to sell our beloved family home, I knew right away Kelly was the perfect fit. From our first consultation all the way through closing, her communication, knowledge and work ethic were all top notch. I highly recommend anyone looking to buy or sell to have Kelly represent you. She and her team all have your back and make a big life decision an easy and enjoyable process.

Michael Radey

2023-08-05

Kelly was an absolute pleasure to work with throughout the entirety of our purchasing process. After dealing with another agents incompetence for 3 months, Kelly provided a breath of fresh air from day 1. Communication was flawless, all questions were answered, and I felt that she truly had our best interest in mind. If you're looking for an agent local to Sarasota, I suggest you look no further, Kelly is most definitely the best option out there.

John

2023-07-25

Kelly is incredibly down to earth and helpful through the transaction process. She's a great and active communicator, which provides added reassurance. As a long time local, she is able to provide insight to the area that is incredibly helpful for those relocating. We felt very well represented!

Anna Mccloskey

2023-07-05

Working with Kelly was one of the must smoothest processes I've ever undergone! As a first time home buyer, I wasn't sure what to expect- she made everything simple, efficient, and was prepared with specs on all of our house visits to answer any questions we could have had. Kelly was set on helping us not just close on a house, but find a home. 12/10 would recommend working with her!

Bob Lammon

2023-05-20

Two years ago we started looking into houses in the Sarasota area. When we found one online, we were very fortunate that Kelly became our agent. Words cannot express how Kelly was so responsive, thorough and such a pleasure to work with. She went up and beyond expectations. If and when another property comes into our interest, Kelly is our choice.

Karen Slabach

2023-05-06

Kelly first listened well to understand my needs and goals as I sold my condo and purchased a house. There was a lot happening… all at the same time in that scenario, but she stayed on top of the details and went above and beyond to help make sure the transactions went smoothly. She's an amazing realtor, but also a delightful, kind person who was a joy to work with.

Kelly Fullick

Sarasota REALTOR®
Curating Gulf Coast luxury living.

Connect

941-260-7770
kelly@kellyfullick.com
423 St. Armands Circle
Sarasota, FL 34236

© 2026 Kelly Fullick. All rights reserved.

Licensed REALTOR® — Coldwell Banker Realty, Sarasota, Florida